4 Core ELT Methods in 10 Minutes: Direct, GTM, Structural & CLT for RPSC Second Grade
Compare grammar translation, direct, structural-situational and communicative teaching methods for RPSC Second Grade English pedagogy.
The pedagogy section of the RPSC Second Grade English exam is one of the most scoring areas for aspirants who prepare it correctly. Unlike literary analysis, pedagogy questions have clear, definite answers — and those answers come from a small set of methods that examiners return to again and again.
This guide covers the four methods you absolutely must know: the Grammar-Translation Method (GTM) , the Direct Method , the Structural-Situational Method , and Communicative Language Teaching (CLT) . Read the master comparison table first, then study the details of whichever method you find hardest.
For full in-depth study, see Methods of Language Teaching on LitGramStudy and Communicative Language Teaching on LitGramStudy.
Feature, GTM, Direct Method, Structural-Situational, CLT Full name , Grammar-Translation Method, Direct Method, Structural (or Audio-Lingual / Situational) Method, Communicative Language Teaching Era , 17th century onwards, Late 19th century (Berlitz), Mid-20th century, 1970s–present Theoretical basis , Classical language teaching, Immersion in target language, Behaviorism + structural linguistics, Dell Hymes' communicative competence Unit of teaching , Word / Sentence, Sentence, Structure / Pattern, Meaning / Function / Context Use of L1 (mother tongue) , Heavy — translation is central, Completely banned, Minimal, Limited (not banned) Primary skill focus , Reading and Writing, Speaking and Listening, Oral pattern practice, All four skills; emphasis on real communication Error correction , Immediate and explicit, Indirect (teacher models correctly), Prevention through correct input, Delayed (after the activity ends) Role of grammar , Explicit grammar rules taught first, Grammar taught inductively through use, Habit formation through drills, Grammar serves communication; not the starting point Typical classroom activity , Translating passages; parsing sentences, Question-answer in target language; object-pointing, Substitution drills; pattern practice, Role-plays; information gap tasks; discussions Strength , Good for reading classical texts, Natural acquisition of spoken language, Systematic habit formation, Develops real communication ability Weakness , Students cannot speak the language, Difficult to maintain without native-speaker teacher, Mechanical; students cannot communicate freely, Less systematic grammar coverage
GTM began as a method for teaching classical languages (Latin and Greek). When modern languages entered schools in the 18th and 19th centuries, teachers simply applied the same approach.
The teacher presents a grammar rule explicitly (e.g., the formation of the passive voice). Students read a passage in the target language (L2). Students translate the passage into their mother tongue (L1). Vocabulary is taught as a bilingual list: English word = Hindi/Rajasthani word. Compositions are written in L2 and corrected for grammatical accuracy.
It does not teach students to speak. It does not put students in real communicative situations. It produces students who can read but cannot hold a conversation.
A common RPSC question asks: "Which method uses translation as the primary technique?" The answer is always GTM . Another common question: "Which method was criticised for producing 'book-worms who cannot speak'?" Again, GTM .
The Direct Method was popularized by Charles Berlitz in the late 19th century as a reaction against GTM. His claim was simple: children learn their mother tongue without translation, so adult learners should learn L2 the same way.
No translation : The mother tongue is never used in the classroom. Objects and actions : New words are taught by pointing to objects or demonstrating actions — never by giving the L1 equivalent. Thinking in L2 : Students are trained to think in the target language from day one. Grammar taught inductively : Students observe patterns and figure out the rule; the teacher does not state it explicitly. Oral work first : Speaking and listening precede reading and writing.
Teacher holds up an apple and says "apple" — never "seb." Teacher mimes "running" and says "He is running" — never uses Hindi. Q&A conducted entirely in L2, even about complex topics.
Questions often ask: "In which method is the mother tongue completely avoided?" Answer: Direct Method . Another trap: students confuse "inductive" (students discover the rule) with "deductive" (teacher states the rule). GTM is deductive ; the Direct Method is inductive .
This method goes by different names in different textbooks, which confuses aspirants. Know these equivalents: Structural Method = focus on language patterns/structures Situational Method = teaching structures in meaningful real-life contexts Audio-Lingual Method = the American version, based on audio recordings and drilling All share the same theoretical basis: Behaviorism (B.F. Skinner's stimulus-response learning theory)