David Copperfield vs That Long Silence: RPSC First Grade Comparison Guide
Compare David Copperfield and That Long Silence for RPSC English: characters, themes, narrative technique and revision points.
The RPSC First Grade English fiction section pairs two very different novels: Charles Dickens's David Copperfield (1850), a sprawling Victorian bildungsroman, and Shashi Deshpande's That Long Silence (1988), a focused Indian feminist novel. Examiners test them individually and as a comparative pair.
This guide gives you the character checklists, thematic analysis, narrative technique notes, and comparison tables you need for a fast, high-scoring revision. For in-depth study, see David Copperfield on LitGramStudy and That Long Silence on LitGramStudy.
Fact, Detail Author, Charles Dickens Published, 1849–50 (serialized in monthly parts; then as a novel) Dickens's own words, Called it "my favourite child" Genre, Bildungsroman (coming-of-age novel); autobiographical fiction Narrator, David Copperfield (first-person, retrospective) Form, Episodic; loosely structured across many years and locations Social context, Victorian England: poverty, orphanhood, class mobility, education Key Victorian concern, Self-improvement through discipline and work
Character, Relationship to David, Key Trait, Exam Significance David Copperfield , Protagonist and narrator, Observant, sensitive, idealistic, slow to see people's true nature, The centre of all action. His growth from naïve child to mature writer is the novel's arc. Agnes Wickfield , Childhood companion; eventual wife, Patient, morally strong, genuinely good, Called "my good angel" by David. Represents the Victorian ideal of the perfect woman — but also genuine moral wisdom. Dora Spenlow , David's first wife, Charming, childish, unwilling to grow, The contrast with Agnes. Dora is the "child-wife." Her death frees David for Agnes, which Dickens frames as growth — though modern readers question this. Uriah Heep , Mr. Wickfield's clerk, False humility, scheming, parasitic, The primary villain. "I'm so very 'umble" is his catchphrase. He uses humility as a weapon of manipulation. Steerforth , David's school friend at Salem House, Charming, charismatic, secretly amoral, He seduces and ruins little Em'ly. His death at sea (dramatically wrapping the plot) is the punishment for his charm. Mr. Micawber , Family friend and serial debtor, Optimistic, eloquent, financially hopeless, "Something will turn up" is his philosophy. Based partly on Dickens's own father, who was jailed for debt. He ultimately exposes Uriah Heep. Aunt Betsey Trotwood , David's eccentric great-aunt, Gruff, independent, deeply kind, She rescues David when he runs away to Dover. She is the most capable character in the novel — and a woman, at a time when women had little legal power. Mr. Murdstone , David's stepfather, Cold, cruel, Calvinist, Represents the repressive Evangelical Christianity of the period. He breaks David's spirit through beatings and rigid discipline. Peggotty , David's nurse, Warm, simple, fiercely loyal, True goodness without education or social standing. A recurring Dickens type: the working-class saint.
1. Education and Self-Formation David goes from being beaten by Murdstone at home and humiliated at the Blacking Factory (a thinly veiled reference to Dickens's own childhood trauma) to becoming a successful writer. The novel argues that character, not birth, determines destiny .
2. Women and Victorian Society The novel offers three models of womanhood: Dora = the decorative ideal (pretty but useless in a crisis) Agnes = the moral ideal (capable, steady, spiritually strong) Aunt Betsey = the independent ideal (refuses the social rules)
Questions often ask: which woman does Dickens respect most, and why?
3. Memory and Narration David is writing the novel as an adult, looking back. This creates a double perspective : the innocent child-David experiencing events, and the wiser adult-David judging them. This technique influenced later novels significantly.
4. The "Undisciplined Heart" Dickens coined this phrase in the novel itself. David's central flaw is his "undisciplined heart" — he loves unwisely (Dora), trusts wrongly (Steerforth), and mistakes charm for goodness. Growth = learning to discipline the heart.
Feature, How Dickens Uses It First-person narration, David tells his own story, creating both intimacy and unreliability Retrospective view, David can see what child-David could not — he often hints at future tragedy Episodic structure, The novel reads like a series of vivid scenes, not a tight plot Comic excess, Characters like Micawber and Uriah Heep are deliberately exaggerated for satirical effect
Study the novel in full: David Copperfield on LitGramStudy David Copperfield on LitGram
Fact, Detail Author, Shashi Deshpande Published, 1988 Award, Sahitya Akademi Award (1990) Genre, Psychological / feminist fiction Narrator, Jaya (first person; stream of consciousness) Setting, Bombay (Mumbai), 1980s Key social context, Middle-class Indian marriage, patriarchy, female identity Central question, What happens to a woman who has silenced herself to preserve her marriage?